Missing from New Milford PA: The Sara Reynolds Case PART 2

 PART 2 Updates 8/7/26- Sara Reynolds Missing since 7/2/26 last seen at HO Mart in New Milford . PA —— If you have any information, leads, or tips EVEN IF YOURE NOT POSITIVE, please call PSP ☎️ 1-800-472-8477 or Trooper Godino PSP Gibson 📱 570-465-3154 🚨 Please Share any and all missing persons flyers you see - even if they’re not from your area, they could end up anywhere and you could save a life 

Transcript

SPEAKER_00 0:00

Hey guys, welcome back to another episode of True Crime with Tip Klein giving criminals disrespect they deserve. Now, this is season three, episode twelve, and this is part two of the supporting Sarah Reynolds. Now, I don't have a criminal to give disrespect to today, but um maybe maybe with all the help of you guys sharing the flyers. You guys are doing a kick-ass job. You guys have been sharing my shit so hard and you know, really supporting the family, and it's much appreciated because this is what it's all about. And I really can appreciate people keeping their opinions and theories and conspiracy theories out of it too. And um, just a little background before I get started. Sarah Reynolds went missing July 2nd, 2026. Last seen at the HL Mart off 492 and I-81 in New Milford, Pennsylvania. She's 130 pounds, about 5'2, has facial piercings, auburn, auburn reddish-brownish hair, um, tattoos, and she was last seen wearing black hay boots, a black sleeveless shirt, and gray leggings. She is a mother of a five-year-old son who she would never abandon. She even missed his birthday, and it's not something she would do. Um, and there have been no leads, there have been no sightings, there have been no nothing. She just vanished. And we know people don't just vanish out of thin air. No, we we know that. But um, I wanted to give some updates because not everybody follows my Facebook. Some people only follow my podcast. So some things I'm gonna read right off my Facebook page, other things are just gonna be me talking as I go. But thank you. Thank you for sharing this information. Thank you for advocating, thank you for helping bring Sarah home. Um, it's I love I love true crime community because people care. Um, the ones who are in it for the right reasons. There are some assholes out there, but for the majority, a lot of people care and they want to help. Um, but it's just very important to keep it ethical. And that's gonna lead me into what I'm about to say. But thank you for tuning in to True Crime with Tiff Klein. And again, this is part two of Missing Woman, Sarah Reynolds Last Scene, New Milford Township, Pennsylvania, which is by the border of New York, and it's about 45 minutes to an hour from Wilkesbury Scranton area, but it's closer to New York. Um, it's up by Montrose and Talkanic. So if you're familiar with those places, I'm just trying to give my listeners a geographical um map here in their heads, but I want to explain something. True crime isn't fiction, these are real people. And I want to explain why I'm so particular about facts, sources, and accuracy when I talk about missing people and true crime cases, right? So I didn't get involved in this because I want to sit behind a screen and invent theories about strangers. That's not why I do it. I don't do it for clickbait, I don't do it for engagement. I don't even have a sponsor on my podcast because that's not what I do it for. If it happened down the road, cool, but it's not why I do it. I do it because I want to help. I got involved because I care, and I host True Crime with Tiff Klein on podcasts and social media because I want to raise awareness. I want to be a voice. I spent time in the past volunteering with the Gabby Petito Foundation, amazing foundation, amazing people. And if you follow True Crime, I know you know who Gabby Petito is. Um, she was a social media influencer. She was traveling across the country in a van with her fiance and unfortunately lost her life by the ends of him. And um, it was national, it was international. You know, she really did touch the world. And because of Gabby, literally, there's been a lot of moss changed and education to police and first responders and in the the classrooms, thanks to her parents, Jim, Tara, Nikki, and Joe. Um, they haven't stopped. They're amazing. And I have such a similar case and story to Gabby's that that's why I got so invested in it. And I remember when she went missing, people in my area would make fun of me and be like, why don't you just help people in your own community? Like, why are you so invested in this one? And but they just because they never knew that I was abused. They never knew my history until I started talking about it. And because of Gabby, I started, but you know what? That that first flyer I saw, Gabby, it's why I started speaking. Because it hit home. It was wow, like that could have been me. Because my ex wanted the van, he wanted to travel, I was a social media influencer, I was strangled. And when you finally you see true crime from a whole different perspective, it's like this light came on, right? So I worked with and spoken to people who are connected to missing people, missing person cases, victims, families, advocates, attorneys, investigators, detectives, journalists, news reporters, deaf and forensic investigators, pathologists, and others who work in the field day in and day out. The people that live these nightmares every day and have PTSD because they face it every day. The people who see what false accusations and conspiracy theories can do to arm a victim, their families, and an investigation. I've met many people face to face. Nancy Grace, Cheryl McCollum. Speaking of Cheryl McCollum, I'm gonna give her a plug here. I've just because I have a book next to me. Swans don't swim in a sewer. Cheryl McCollum is a crime scene investigator, actually in the crime scene investigation hall of fame. She's coming out with a show about Alcatraz on the Discovery Channel, so stay tuned. Cheryl's in Deal Deal, a dear friend of mine, um, and she wrote this book about Melissa Wolfenberger going missing in 1998, and she actually worked with her father, who was the Flint River killer in Georgia, to solve her case behind bars. She only did it through phone calls and notes talking to her father. Her father didn't do it, but he helped solve her case. And I actually interviewed her sister Tina Patton a few episodes back if you want to give a listen. Um, but that's Cheryl McCollum. And um, you know, obviously I've met Gabby's parents. I've met Jesse Weber from Long Crime, Vinnie Polliton from Fort TV, Colby Ryan, whose mom Glory Vallow killed his siblings, Tylee and J. Jane, buried them in the backyard, Joseph Scott Morgan, John Ramsey, Marsha Clark, who was the prosecutor in the O.J. Simpson case, Brian Eton, um, previously of News Nation, the families of Habby and Libby of the Delphi case, Nate Eaton of East Idaho News, and so much more. So many more. I've met a ton of podcasters who also have ethics and morals. They're on the same mission. They're focusing on victims, keeping the victims in the spotlight, not the abusers, not the perpetrators, and advocacy. There's even an advocacy con, which it's in New Mexico this time. I really wish I could go. I hope to go eventually. Um, I've been to CrimeCon twice, once in Denver, once in Vegas. Amazing. I've I've met so many people. I found my tribe, I found my community. And again, because I've known Gabby's parents, I've seen firsthand how theories and false information can hurt them, can hurt families in general, victims, investigators. I've talked to these people, I've heard stories, I've hugged them, they've cried, I've witnessed tears from podcasters, I've witnessed tears from mothers whose daughters have been missing for decades and they have no answers. Now, that leads me to my next point. My dear friend Joanne Lowitzer's daughter, Allie, went missing in Spring, Texas in April of 2010. She literally vanished. And her mother has had no leads and no tips since 2010. She pushes every single day to get up and bring her daughter home. And she's had her fair share of rumors and fair share of people being nasty and assholes just for clickbait and engagement. But she keeps going. Imagine waking up every day not knowing what happened to your daughter. Now, Allie, I did do an episode on this. Allie got off the school bus and wanted to walk to work. Something she's she was never allowed to do. And the one time she was allowed, she vanished. And I also met Dr. Maggie, whose daughter Brittany Phillips, I also did a podcast episode on in season one. I've met Maggie. I hold her near and dear to my heart. She drives a caravan to catch a killer. You may see me post about this purple van with Brittany's face all over it. She travels to different states trying to help people find their missing loved ones. And she's always taking donations. I think last I talked to her, she hit 25 trips with 340,000 miles. So I'm always supporting Miss Maggie. Um, you know, imagine Gabby Petito's parents seeing everybody's cruel comments online and all their lies and bullshit. Guys, I saw the autopsy. 47 pages. The media is at fault for a lot of this, a lot of the rumors, a lot of the misconceptions. They pick and choose what they want that can be a headline and they go with it. They spin it. Now, dirty laundry, his story was out of that they only found two bones. No, no, no. They found all, all but two bones. So that's that's why it's really important to put out information that's factual. Um, and to clear it up, no, his brother and cousin was not a dentist, no, his father was not a retired NYPD, and his mother doesn't currently work with a DA. So this is what I'm talking about. And I'm only using that as an example because that case went wild, people. Wild. The most wild theories and conspiracy theories I've ever heard came up with the Gabby Petito case. And I, you know, after meeting her parents and talking to them quite often, I don't much anymore because they travel and they're so busy, but I I touch base once in a while. But um, you know, they didn't deal with these stupid ass nine rumors. And they came to CrimeCon and pled and begged people to stop putting out false information that Brian, dirty laundry, is actually dead, guys. He's he's dead. Please let it go. I'm still seeing the shit online. Um, but that that's where I'm getting at. That's the whole point of this. It's the conspiracy theories that hurt families and the investigations. And I didn't meet them, you know, all these people just once. I've met them multiple times. I've talked to a lot of them almost every day. You know, the podcasters, the reporters, the pathologists, the forensic scientists. And I've stayed in contact, but I'm not, I'm not just another armchair detective. I'm not a, you know, internet sleuth. I'm an advocate. I'm a domestic violence survivor. So I use my voice for the voiceless. And the last thing I want to do is put out information that's not factual. And the more I become invested, the more strongly I feel about this, okay? Facts matter. Accuracy matters, words matter. Social media has created a world where somebody can post a theory, another person repeats it, someone makes a TikTok about it, and suddenly thousands of people are repeating something as fact. And that was never confirmed in the first place. That's dangerous. In this entire person's case, is not an episode of TV, guys. It's not a show like Sopranos Breaking Bad in Great Anatomy. There's no script. So it's real people. And people just get on TikTok and believe whatever they read. And suddenly thousands of people are repeating something as quote fact that was never confirmed in the first place. That's dangerous. These are real people, folks. Real mothers, real fathers, refreshing their phones, refreshing their newsfeeds every day, hoping for news. Real children, real parents missing, real families wondering whether someone they love is ever coming home. Real investigators trying to separate legitimate information from bullshit noise that's going around on the internet. And when the internet starts creating rumors, accusing people without evidence, manipulating information, or building conspiracy theories around incomplete facts, it doesn't necessarily hope quell or quote solve this case. Okay? Sometimes it adds more chaos, it adds more fuel to the fire. Yes, ask questions. Absolutely. Question inconsistencies, look at timelines, examine evidence, discuss possibilities, ask why something doesn't match or make sense. Okay, now I will say this. I've seen Nancy Grace speak twice, and I've met her. And yeah, she is nice. She's not this evil woman that everybody sees on TV. She is an advocate for victims and victims' families. And I don't know if you know this, but how she got into journalism and news reporting and being a prosecutor is because her fiance got murdered right before they got married. So she changed her whole direction in life. And that's why she gets so passionate and so just calling people out on her bullshit because it happened to her. She is not just the prosecutor or news reporter who wants clicks. She had her fiance murdered. Okay. There's a reason why she's the way she is. And I love her. I support her 100%. I dreamed of being Nancy Grace. So, yes, look at it. Now, people might say, well, Tiff, you know, you're a you're on social media, you're posting stuff all the time. There's a difference between what I post and what I think. Okay. I've been a social media marketing manager since 2013 for many restaurants and local businesses. I've also been in sales and marketing for local radio for seven years, and now I'm in insurance. The reason now people are gonna come at me for this because I have tattoos. It doesn't affect how I do my job. I have a mouth like a sailor. Guess what? It doesn't affect my job. I've overly posted information and my friends come at me for it. I have said things that made me look unhinged and not good. Care. I don't have regrets. And people will judge me for it. I have posted that I don't like something with watermelon. And because as a food photographer and social media influencer, I could say, I don't like this martini because it's watermelon. But if you love watermelon, you're gonna love this. And they would forget the last part and just come at me because I don't like watermelon at a certain restaurant. If I said one chef cooked this lobster amazingly, but left out the rest of their staff, I got hung at the cross. If I said somebody had great customer service, but I didn't like their food, I got hung at the cross. I'm not allowed to have an opinion in social media. And that's why I fucking love having a podcast because it's a place where I can be me. It's my platform. I can say whatever the fuck I want. And people will either follow me because they enjoy it, or they'll unfollow me because they don't. I don't ever have people getting on Facebook messaging saying, I unfollowed your podcast because I don't like you. And if they did, I'd be like, all right, thanks for the honest feedback. Have a good day. Like, everybody that knows me knows because working in social media, and I'm getting somewhere of this, I promise. I don't wear a mask. What you see is what you get. I'm not gonna be someone on camera or behind the microphone and be different than I am a person. I'm unfortunately the same menace I am behind the microphone and behind the keyboard. So I'm very transparent. I'm very I'm a whistleblower. A lot of people don't like it. I'm very ambitious, headstrong, I'm loud, I'm opinionated, I'm aggressive, I'm pushy. And usually every goal I set for myself, I achieve, you know, within means, you know. And when I was in Crimecon in Vegas, I had a few, you know, conversations with Joe Petito. I love Joe Petito. Um, and if you've ever seen him on TV or social media, one person like I have, he holds a room's attention. People listen to what Joe Petito has to say. And there was a video that he did um way back when Gabby was still missing, and he stood in front of people, the media, people who came out to the court, and there was an easel of Gabby behind him. And he said, This is what matters. Bringing Gabby home, finding Gabby, this is the priority, this is what matters. And he said it kind of like that. Now I'm read I'm paraphrasing it just a little bit. But he's, you know, he always said that it's the media's fault. You know, they didn't have a choice, they didn't ask to have Gabby's case go viral. They're thankful. They are so thankful because it led to finding Gabby. But they want the attention of every missing person's case that Gabby had, and that they strive for that. And they openly say it every day. But he looked at it instead of that picture of Gabby. So that's what matters. And that's kind of where I'm getting at here. But when I had a I had a conversation with him in in Vegas again, and I've talked to Joe quite a few times, but um, I I um met them in person in Vegas, or I'm sorry, in Denver Crime Con in September 2025. But I've been talking to them online for like two or three years. And I I've talked to Nicki and Woz daily with texting and what uh whatnot, and Tara occasionally. I don't talk to Jim and Joe often because they're often their own thing, but um I was fortunate enough to have a few uh I like to say how are they called? I'm I found out I was loaded to them. They have mango in them. Um palamos or I don't know how you say it. I can't remember. There's the palamos with the potatoes or something like that. And I would laugh. But I had I had a few. It was like two in the morning. And I went outside, talk to Joe, and um I said, Joe, how do you hold how do you hold someone's attention? Like how do you root how do you hold a room of attention like like you do? Because he's like, he's very stern. And when Joe walks into a room, like you can feel his presence, and he's very, he's very nice, but he's very like he speaks and you shut the fuck up. Like that's Joe. Like that that's my you know experiences with him. But he's very kind and he's fun, he's funny as hell. But he just has this aura around him that when he speaks, you're gonna listen. And I was like, how do you do this and get people to listen without being an asshole? Because he knows he knows I'm very opinionated and I'm very loud and you know, forward and blunt, and I don't have a filter 99% of the time. And I was like, I know you know, like that's how I am, but like, how can I like tune it back, scale it back some so I don't come off as this over-aggressive, opinionated asshole? And because I've been in sales, he's been in sales, he's like, All right, you know, like when you go to make a sales pitch, do you like aggressively come at people and like demand that they listen to you and believe you? Or do you try to have a conversation and be open-minded and you know, this, that, and the other? Um, you see where I'm getting at here, he's he said. And I'm like, Yeah, I get it. And he goes, and this is something he said that I'll take with me. And it's been on my mind every single day since the last night at Krancon in Vegas was the end of May, early June. He says, You don't always have to be the loudest person in the room to be heard. And I just went silent, and then he had to go to the bathroom when he went in to Caesar's. But I was like, like it just stuck to me um at two o'clock in the morning, and I'm like, I mean, I'm a voice for the voiceless, but sometimes I am too loud. I will admit it. Sometimes I I overextend myself. Sometimes I say things and I'm just like, I sound like like a mean or an asshole, but I'm not. It's just because I'm passionate. And when I get passionate about something, my friends know that like I will use my voice. And because I'm a domestic violence survivor, I won't stay silent to make other people comfortable. So I wanted to make you know this podcast about part two about Sarah, but I also really wanted to focus on the importance of being assertive, but not being an asshole, being aggressive, but not being mean, um, getting your point across without cutting other people down, putting out factual information. And people will say, like, well, Tiff, you're, you know, you're on social media and you put out information and you're on TikTok, you're on Facebook, but there's a difference. I talk to the families and I talk to their advocates and I get the facts. Even with Sarah's case, I posted updates today and I sent her the post before I posted it and said, Is this okay to post? Is there anything that I'm not allowed to say, or is anything on here not not true? She approved that I posted all of it. So I want to make that very clear. Now, the other day, I got information from another family member that Sarah went to rehab near Lancaster. So I put that out there where they someone thought they saw her. And actually the information was wrong. She went to rehab three hours from Lancaster and another one in New Jersey. And I got on and I corrected it and I apologized. And you know, that that that wasn't the correct information. And you would assume, because it came from the family member, that it would be accurate. But now moving forward, I'm only going to speak to her mother. And um everything I've been posting, her mom has approved at this point. And um there's things like no that I'm allowed to talk about. There's things that I don't know because she's not allowed to talk about. So I respect that. You know, working with the La La Clark case and Wolf's bear, um, I did a five-part podcast on her. She is the 15-year-old deaf girl who went missing in January and his body was found in February, and her life is taken by the hands of her aunt. And um I've been in constant contact with her parents and her family advocates in state one. And I don't post anything without their permission. I don't come up with my own theories and post them. I don't post opinions. Now, going back to what I just said, I'm a very opinionated person. But when it comes to true crime, I have Being that way. Because after I met the Petitos, I learned that I was ignorant, putting out my own theories. I was ignorant, you know, putting out my videos on TikTok, trying to connect the dots or if Dirty Laundry was actually alive and what his parents were doing. And I had no nothing to fucking back it up. And I never realized how harmful that is until I met them, until I met other families whose loved ones have gone missing or have been murdered. And you see the tears in their eyes and you hug them and you feel their pain. And they just want the truth out there. And they're overshadowed by all these rumors that circulate, all these conspiracy theories on things that people think they know and they don't, guys. It's again, you know, question everything, but there's a huge difference between raising questions and saying this is what happened when you don't have evidence to prove it. There's a difference between a theory and a fact. There's a difference between suspicion and evidence. There's a difference between asking questions and publicly accusing someone of a crime, and there's a difference between advocating for answers and creating a conspiracy because the truth isn't dramatic enough. If something is unconfirmed, then say this is unconfirmed. If something is your theory, then say this is my theory. If you discover that something you shared was wrong, grow some balls, take some accountability, do the right thing, and correct it. There's absolutely no shame, none, in saying, I got that wrong, but here's the correct information. Like I said, I literally had that happen to me the other day. And I corrected it and moved on from it. And now I have the real information to move on with. And if I put that information out there too long, it could have got to the wrong eyes, the wrong ears, and things could have spiraled out of control. So I I was like, I was really upset that I did that, like really upset. But again, I took I took information from another family member thinking that it was accurate, um, but it wasn't. So um, you know, I I'd rather correct myself publicly than knowingly allow misinformation to continue spreading. I don't give a shit who posts something first. I don't care if it takes somebody a month to post something. If it's the right information, that's all that matters. Because being first doesn't help a family if you're wrong, doesn't help the victim, and it sure as hell doesn't help the investigation. So going viral does not matter. It's it doesn't make something true. Thousands of people share things that are ran on a woman and they turn it into evidence. And well, they try. And sometimes someone's, you know, someone's tragedy should never become an opportunity to manufacture a more entertaining story. It just shouldn't. I love true crime. I love investigating, researching, asking uncomfortable questions, examining different personalities and possibilities, and giving victims a voice. But the difference is I learned from being an ignorant asshole and being a couch detective in the past because I've met people who've gone through this. I have hugged them and shed tears with them. And now I realize how bad and how harmful and hurtful it is, guys. I have a friend, Hope Hogan. You can follow her on Facebook and Instagram on Hope in the Pain. She's also a podcast host of Voices Against Philicide. Philicide is the actual term of when parents take the lives of their children. She is an advocate for philosophy because she's lit it. Her ex-hus estranged husband had some mental health issues. There's actually an episode where I interviewed her on this podcast, and I have her book, but I've met her in person, um, have her, you know, as a friend, and her husband was having mental health episodes, and she kept warning that kids weren't safe with him, and he wasn't safe for himself. Nobody listened, they kept the custody 50-50, and unfortunately he took their lives and then his. So she's out changing laws in Arizona. She got the Alec and Lydia law passed. That's the names of her kids. So if you get on her Facebook or Instagram, you'll see pink and green for Alec and Lydia. And she got laws changed that the Gorks have to have good justification and reasoning on why they want to um remove or keep kids in the home, or um, you know, go over every dotted line and you know, dot the I's across the T's, and they have to write a statement backing up what they're doing. And she's also trying to get the law changed in Michigan too. And people like that, when you meet people like that whose kids were murdered by the hands of their father when they were in his custody for the weekend, where somewhere that where she thought they were safe. You can you imagine? Can you imagine being that person? Do you imagine being my friend Miss Joanne, who's woke up every day since April 2010, not having one tip or lead on where her daughter is, and people sending her false shit, or people claiming things that aren't true, and and they get their hopes up and then they're broken and shattered all over again? Do you imagine if that was you or if someone that you loved went missing? And these people beg and plead and get on their knees and spend every financial mean they have to bring their local ones home and get answers, and you can't take two seconds to share a missile person's flyer. Think about that for a second. Think about the importance if somebody that you loved went missing, you would be asking everybody to share that fly. Because all it takes is one set of eyes and one set of ears. Now, I've had people message me, well, should I share this? Should I share that? They're not from my area, they're not from my state. Yes. Always share it. Doesn't matter who, what, where, when, or why. Because you never know where a missing person's gonna end up, where they're gonna pass through. You just never know. And it takes one pair of pair of eyes. Now, I remember a few months back, there was a little girl missing. It made national news, I cannot remember her name, and she was abducted. And these movers were in another state, and they saw her. And the guy's like, that looks like the little girl from the missing flyers poster. So they called in the police. They actually barricaded the woman's car and she couldn't get out because they had a big moving truck until the authorities got there and they did find discovered that it was that little girl, and that was in a whole different state. And because that guy had seen her flyer floating around Facebook, he recognized her. That is why you should post and share every person's social media flyer. Guys, I've perfected, I have perfected my algorithm where I don't see shit. I don't see bullshit. I don't see politics, I don't see what people are arguing about. There's actually a setting in Facebook where you can turn off or show limited amount of politic posts. My algorithm is so good now that all I see is true crime stuff and all the people I follow or food. I don't pay attention to the background noise. I don't, I don't see it. I have literally perfected it. Like when ads pop up or posts that I see of people I'm not even following or friends with, I just kept hitting not interested, not interested, not interested. And I mentioned my algorithm was like, oh no, she's not playing. Like she only wants to see this shit. So, and you know, if you scroll past a flyer, if you don't want to share it, at least comment and like it. Because what you're doing is you're helping their algorithm. The more people engage with it, especially if you give it hearts, like love the post instead of liking it, it's more likely to show up in someone's news feed. The more people who interact with it, the more it's gonna get boosted into the Facebook algorithm. So if you don't want to share it for your own reasons, at least like the post so it gets more active and more people see it. It takes one set of eyes and one set of ears to save a life, guys. And if it was your loved one, you would be begging everybody to share that flyer. It baffles me, and this is gonna be me where you know I get loud and aggressive and pushy and forward. It baffles me that people will share the most asining, ignorant, unproductive bullshit on social media. You're quick to share something funny, and I again we all share funny shit. We all need to laugh because this world sucks. But people would rather post inaccurate information and argue with each other, especially politics, than post a missing person's flyer try to save somebody. And please, please make that make sense. Make that make sense, please. Now, I've been recovering from surgery. I had laparoscopic heliosis uh a week ago where I had scar tissue brewing in my organs, stretching like bubblegum, sticking to my organ and my abdominal wall, just stretching. Now that's scar tissue from two previous abdominal surgeries, and that's the only cure of surgery. I've had a lot of time to sit and research and get facts and talk to people about Sarah's case. I've had a lot of time to do my due diligence and research myself. And, you know, I ask questions, but I don't post saying I think this is who did it, or this has to be who did it. That's so dangerous. Not only for you, your well-being, because if somebody is on hinge and they, you know, they do take someone else's life and they know that you're out there spreading that information. Guys, protect yourselves, you know, first and foremost, protect yourself. I'm never gonna post a theory ever again. Ever since I met Gabby's parents, I I will not, I will say my opinion. I will say, like, I have my thoughts about this, but I'm not gonna post it. Because it takes one post to ruin a life, it takes one post to destroy your life, and um, you could put yourself in danger. But I I do want to make it known that when I post things, it I am not pointing fingers, I'm not accusing people, I'm not putting blame on people, I'm not the cops, I'm not the parents involved, I'm not the family investigators, I'm not the victim. Who the fuck am I to get on there and say, well, this is what happened, this is who did it. Like, you know, the whole John Bene Ramsey case was twisted and put out of just, I've met John Bene's dad and her brother. And that's another case like I could talk to in my sleep, and it would make sense. But I will never sit here and give out who I think did it and why or where. Now, I will say who I don't think did it, because that's less, you know, accusatory than saying something who did, who didn't. But the media took that one, and I, you know, they they fed the people what they wanted for so long that people believed what the media put out without getting the facts themselves. And you know, because I've I've met John Ramsey and Burke, I've looked in their eyes, I've hugged John. And when you're standing in front of them, it's a whole different experience. But they true crime is true crime for a reason. Guys, pay attention to the word true, okay? And yes, people are manipulators, people are gaslighters, people are abusers, and people get away with murder every day. We get it, we know that. Okay, we know that. But don't forget the word true. You know, we're not going, I think this is what happened crime, or maybe this is what happened crime, or well, I saw it on TikTok, so this is the truth crime. It's these are real people, it's true, it's real people, not TV. And, you know, it's just very important that you don't accuse people. You can say all day, you know, you can do and say what you want. Again, I'm not your boss, and um, I'm just trying to give a tip on how it affects you and it affects others, and protect yourself. And I'm not gonna get on here and say who I think did this or that, where, when, why, or how. All I'm gonna do is tell you what I know that are facts from the family. That's it. I can have my opinion. It doesn't mean I have to put it online because that's not important. What happens, where it happened, is important. But the most important thing is where these victims are, to bring them home, to find them. Everything else will come later. That should be the priority. Okay, and I have learned that from Joe Petito. That should be the priority, finding the person. Everything else takes a backseat because you can come up with all these theories and all these conspiracy theories as you want, but that's all they are theories, because you don't have any evidence to back them up. So once you have Sarah or whoever else is missing, then you can go from there, right? Sometimes you have to start backwards to go forward. Now, I will get into Sarah in one second, because again, this is part two, and uh, but I just thought this this was very important to stress because I've had a lot of people come into my DMs telling me this, that, and the other. Some people are trying to argue what I'm putting out. Not a lot, only like three or four. Um, but then I I present that message to Sarah's mom, and she's like, Yeah, no, that's not true. Or no, that's don't listen to that. Or that person's not a good, you know, a reliable source, I should say. Um, there's always gonna be people out there that oppose what you're saying, right? And I'm open, I'm open to hearing everybody, but I'm not gonna turn around and say, Oh, well, this person said this in my messenger this morning, so I'm not gonna run to Facebook now and put up a new update. That's not an update. That's just hearsay. And I said it to her mom, and if her mom said yes, that's true, that's an update I would have said as such, but I didn't post it because it's not true. See? See how easy it is? See how easy that is, guys. It would have been so irresponsible of me to take those messages and just update people on Facebook and say, I heard this today, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. That's gonna hurt a lot of people, a lot of victims, and a lot of investigations. Like, don't do it. And don't stop, stop, stop. And if set people involved were involved, and people want to keep spiling that and putting that out there, that's on you. But don't be coming to my page saying that I'm saying somebody has involved. The only thing I can say about any case that I work on is I give names and situations and facts, times, places of what happened to that person leading up to it, or facts that I have as it's going along. I don't say what my theory is or my opinion is that I'm not, because my opinion doesn't matter, guys. It doesn't matter what I think or who did it. What matters is finding Sarah and finding all the missing people and bringing them home. That's what matters the most. What I think and what you think don't matter because it's just like that. It's a thought, it's a theory, it's a hypothesis, it's a maybe, it's a conspiracy, it's not evidence, it's not fact. So it doesn't matter at the end of the day. You can have all your thoughts and feelings on that as you want. You can unfollow me, you can whatever. You can curse at me in my DMs. I don't really give a shit because I don't care. And second, you're hurting yourself and you're hurting the victim. Again, if you go point fingers at people and they're not a good person and they're not mentally all there and they're unhinged and they have a history of violence, you might want to watch your back. That's all I'm saying. Like you just never know. And I I'm just saying, like, I don't know, I don't know who who is involved with Sarah's case. I don't know them personally. I don't know who the people are that last saw her. I'm not pointing fingers at them. I'm not sitting here going, well, they did it, because a lot of you are. A lot of you out there are all saying immediately that they did it. Now, I can understand why you think that because Sarah has had a history of dating this man on an office high school with history of abuse. I because I'm in the best at my own survivor, I 100% understand why you think that, but it doesn't make it true. Someone can be an abuser, it doesn't make them a murderer. Okay? Now, the chances of that being accurate were low, because most abusers murder people, but it doesn't make it the truth every single time. Just because someone dropped somebody off somewhere, like his mother dropped Sarah off at the HO mark, doesn't mean she had anything to do with it. It doesn't immediately mean necessarily that she knows exactly what happened. When, where, where, where, why, and how. Maybe she just dropped Sarah off, hung on at the gas station, and that's all she knows. I'm not saying that's the truth, and I'm not saying it's not the truth. I'm just saying that's all the information we have. You can go back and forth on it all day. You can be black, you can be white, you can be red, you can be green, you can be up, you can be down, you can be black or white, whatever. Just because she had an abusive relationship, and just because his mother saw her last and dropped her off does not mean that those two people are the people. It could have been anybody, guys. It could have been anybody. Maybe she hitchhiked and got into somebody's car. Maybe she met up with somebody that recognized her and she got in their car. Maybe it was just some random person hanging out in the woods. You don't know. You cannot just assume because it makes sense to you that that's the truth. A lot of things make sense. Doesn't mean it's true, you know. Um, so there's a responsibility that comes with having a microphone and a platform. Okay, you don't get to just forget that there's a human being behind the headline. And there aren't characters, these aren't storylines, these aren't mysteries created for our entertainment. Okay, that that's someone's daughter, son, mother, father, sister, brother, best friend, aunt, uncle, cousin, grandparents, neighbor, coworker, colleague. So, yeah, it's like I'll keep asking questions and I'll keep digging and I'll keep advocating, but I'll keep telling these stories, but not without the facts or speaking to somebody who's actually involved in the case. Otherwise, it's hearsay and it's bullshit and it's gonna hurt the investigation, it's gonna hurt the victims. I don't have a sponsor on this podcast, guys. Like I said, I don't give a shit. If it came in time, cool. If not, cool. Like I do it because I want to help people, because I like helping people. Facts are rumors. Facts from rumors, guys. You need to separate facts from rumors, evidence from speculation, questions from accusations, and truth from content. Because victims and their families deserve more than you getting engagement in clicks and roses thrown at you on TikTok. They deserve the truth, they deserve to know where their loved one is, and they deserve to have answers in the hall. So that's my rant on that. I'm I'm trying my best not to be aggressive and unfiltered and overly opinionated, but it's important. It's important that I say it. But now into Sarah's case, part two, Sarah Reynolds went missing July 2nd, 2026, off of Route 492 and I-81 in New Milford, PA. Now, New Milford is by the New York border, and it's about an hour from Scranton Wolf's Bear area, just to give you an idea for my listeners. She was last seen wearing the black sleeveless shirt, gray hate her, gray leggings, and black hate-dudes. She has a five-year-old son who she would never abandon. She missed his birthday, something she would never do. She has facial piercings, auburnish, reddish, brownish hair, brown eyes, and about 130 pounds at 5'2. That's all I know about her. That's those are the facts that I know about Sarah Reynolds. Now, some other facts that her mother has confirmed. Yes, she had drug problems in the past. Yes, she's been to rehab. She's been getting her life together. And um, she was dating this person who from high school back and forth, back and forth, back and forth, who has a history of domestic violence. This person was also recently arrested for, you know, throwing, kicking, I don't know the exact word, his most recent girl down the steps. She called the cops. Now, this is a girl that he started seeing right after Sarah disappeared, maybe before, I don't know. I'm not in a love triangle. I don't know exactly what happened. I just know he used to see Sarah, and then he abused this new girl, she called the cops. Now, I don't know if that other girl's talking to him again, but he claimed from messages that I've seen that Sarah was his world, and he never abused her, never did anything, and um then he turns around and gets arrested for assault for somebody else. So, you know, take it, take that as you want it. I don't know, I wasn't there, but you can't sit there and say you're not an abuser, and then a few days later you're arrested because you push a girlfriend for your new girl down the steps. Like, and other people are saying, and I've seen screenshots of messages to her family and other people that they only dated for a month that they didn't know each other in high school, but that's a lot of people are saying that's false information, and um, I'm going by what her mother says. And her mother says they dated on an option side school. And I also have a very close friend who I've known since 2018. Her son also used to date Sarah, so she knows the truth. And I won't mention who that is, but she even told me that. So there haven't been many updates, but again, I'm not pointing fingers. I'm not saying her on again off the gun boyfriend did this. I'm not saying his mother did this. I'm not saying either of them know anything. And now you're gonna come at me and go, well, how could you not? It's like how stupid are you? It's not the fact that it's stupid, it's a fact that I don't fucking know the truth. I don't have the evidence or the facts, guys. So I I just wanted to say that because my DMs are blowing up, you know, people saying that it's them, it's them, it's them. Like, believe and say what you want online, but I'm not gonna do it. But I would highly encourage you not to. Again, for the safety of you and your own family, and that you don't ruin somebody else's life. You know, if it comes out later, that it comes out. But right now, it doesn't matter who, where, when, why, it matters where Sarah is to bring her home. That's that's what matters. And that's all we can focus on right now. That what you think happened does not matter. It literally serves no purpose. None. It's just spreading more rumors, and it's like the telephone game. The most important thing you can do is share her flyers, try to talk to her family, get facts yourself. But don't just get on TikTok and Facebook and say, Well, I think this happened, or there's no way that they these two had anything to do with it. No, you don't know that. They could or couldn't have. It's black or white, up or down, white, red or green, like you know, that that's it. They either did or they didn't. But you putting pieces together and saying that they did doesn't mean that they did, guys. Calm down. Okay. And I'm not defending anybody. I'm not accusing anybody. I'm trying to be Switzerland here and be neutral and point out the fact that it can be dangerous to accuse somebody when you don't have the evidence to back it up. Um, so just be careful what you post. Be careful, be very conscientious of what you post, what you say, because you can't take it back, especially when it's online. Now, not with screenshots, guys. I've been through court enough with my ex. I save every screenshot. I save everything because you're not gonna gaslight me in front of the judge. Ain't happening. We're gaslight the judge. So just be mindful of how you're projecting this case. Try to lean your opinion and feelings about it out of it, and just focus on bringing Sarah. Um, there haven't been really any new updates. Again, I was told a few things I'm not allowed to say, and then there's a few things her mom knows that she's not allowed to say. But what I do know, and what I can share, I have posted this morning and yesterday that I had full permission from her mom to post what I posted. Um she looked at it and said, it was good to go. Because I'm not gonna post something now after what happened two days ago. I posted a little bit of information that was wrong, and then I had to go and correct myself, edit a video, take the post down, repost it, because it could have, it could have harmed it. And I took accountability, I apologize, she wasn't mad, but you know, it was just the wrong location of where she went to rehab. And I'm not gonna say that's all because that could be very serious. You know, if they're looking in a certain area and people think she went to rehab there, which she didn't, and then it caused a mess. So I corrected it. But now moving forward, like I sent her on my post this morning and said, Is there anything wrong with this? Is there anything I'm not allowed to mention? Or is there anything you'd like to add? She goes, Looks good to me. So I had her full permission to post what I posted. So for those who don't follow me on Facebook and only listen, updates as of August 7th, 2026. Okay, Sarah Reynolds, obviously, like I said, went missing July 2nd, 2026, last seen at the H.O. Mart in New Milford, PA. There was, again, was a possible lead that Sarah was seen in Lancaster area, which is Elizabethtown, on or around August 4th or August 5th. On August 6th, the surveillance footage was reviewed, and the woman had short blonde hair and appeared older than Sarah. Sarah's mother believes it was not her after all. However, we cannot dismiss it completely. I also want to clear up the inaccurate info. So, a lot, you know, somebody said that she was near Etown, which is Elizabethtown. This is not the area where Sarah went to rehab in 2019 or 2020. It was actually in Cherry Hill, New Jersey, and Langhorn, BA, which is three hours from Lancaster. So those who didn't see my updated post but saw my videos before I edited them, please know that she did not go to rehab in Lancaster or Elizabethtown. So take it out the window. The photo attached that I have left social shows an arrow. And it's confirmed by Sarah's mom that that's where she left on foot, across from HOMAR, after her on again, off again boyfriend's mother dropped her off. She took off on foot and walked up that hill. The mandor of the HOMA has little footage, and I did ask her mom if the footage from the surveillance could be released to social media, and she doesn't she doesn't think it can. It could be, I don't know. I don't know who has it. I don't know if the police has it, I don't know if the gas station still has it, I don't know. So a lot of you asked me that question, and that's my answer. I don't know. I haven't seen the footage. I'd like to, but I haven't seen it. Um new reports have come in that Sarah's ex, again, the the guy who claims he never abused her and only, you know, she was his world, um, again, was arrested for domestic violence on a new girlfriend right after Sarah disappeared. She called the Aforties on him. The HO mark is approximately eight or so miles from his mom's house. His mom was the last to see Sarah, dropping her off at the HO Mart. She stayed another 15 minutes at the HO Mart, apparently, according to her mom, playing the slots and using the car for a few minutes too. The same car that the Pennsylvania State Police was looking for on Cartoon Road in Montrose. He, meaning the on again off again boyfriend, and his mom, neither have shared any info on Sarah's disappearance except one time on Facebook. There has been a search party, and the Pennsylvania State Police have gone there about four times, but an officer has to be present now if there's a search party because the lock got broken on a gate. I guess it was private property, and the owner got pissed off. So if they do it again, there has to be a cop present. Don't go wandering on people's property, guys. It's not cool. Pennsylvania State Police have been working on getting cell phone data, so that's in the works. I don't have any more updates on that, but they are trying to get, I don't know if they needed to search for it to get the information, like the text, or if they're trying to locate the pin, you know, the last pin where it was. I'm not positive, but this is crucial right here. I think this is the most important evidence I've gotten. Not evidence, but information I've gotten. The day before Sarah disappeared, she contacted a former boyfriend. She had a black eye, not for him, but from this on-again, off again person. And then she blocked him on Snapchat. And we're not sure if it's because the on-again, off again boyfriend made her or what. But the photos that she had a black eye with disappeared, and this former boyfriend wasn't sure how Snapchat worked like that. He did reach out to Sarah's mom and told her this. Um and I I got that information from her mom, and I saw the message. So um from him. And uh he knew there was history of abuse, and he kept saying, like, I need more information, so if something happens, I can help you. And she finally told him, but um, or didn't give him the full information, but like he knew he knew that there it was abusive, but didn't have all the facts, but he knew enough. Um, and he kept asking her to give him all the information. That's what it was. So she did reach out to the day before she disappeared. And I'm not saying he did it, I'm just saying, like, she reached out to him as a confidant, someone she trusted and needed help. Um, but that that's really all the only updates we have, guys. Like, there isn't a lot. And I, you know, as much as this is getting shared and talked about, I wish somebody would say something. Somebody knows something. Sarah did not just walk up a hill and vanish in thin air. People don't vanish, they don't turn to stone, they don't turn to sand, they don't turn to dust, just walking on a road. So either she got in someone's car or someone ambushed her, took her hostage, kidnapped her, threw in the car, took her life, has her captive in the basement. I I don't know. I'm just giving ideas of what could have happened. Because anything is possible, right? Anything's possible. And you know, unless she fell in the woods, uh I doubt it because the police know her founder of war trips out there and search already. No. So she she got in the car with somebody or was dragged on foot. That that's plausible. That that's it's possible that those two things happened. Okay. Now, again, that's not a fact. So don't quote me. All I'm saying is people don't disappear and vanish into the woods or on a road. So she either had to kept keep walking and she got in the car with someone, or someone ambushed her and took her. I mean, that that's those are the most believable concepts here. So again, what we do know is Sarah was last seen in black hay dudes, a black sleeveless shirt and great leggings. She's the mother of a five-year-old who she'd never leave abandoned. She missed his birthday party, something she would never do. She has a history of drug use and has been in and out of rehab. There is a history of domestic violence with her on again, off again boyfriend from high school, the man whose mother dropped her off to the HO Mart, then stayed another 15 minutes after Sarah left on foot across the street and going up the hill. The HO Mart is off Route 492 in I-81 in Milford PA. She has facial piercings, which her eyebrows and nose, what appears to be dermals or gems near her eyes in some of the photos. She's 130 pounds, 5'2, and has auburned-colored hair. Now, this is part two. I've done a podcast, which was season three, episode 11, and that's also available on Spotify, YouTube, iHeart, Apple, and Amazon. And if you have any information, leads, or tips, even if you're not positive, please call Pennsylvania State Police at 1-800-472-8477. Again, that's the Pennsylvania State Police 1-800-472-8477. Or you can contact Trooper Godino of the Gibson Police Department. 570-465-3143154. Again, that's Trooper Godino of Gibson 570-465-3154. Please share any and all missing persons flyers you see, guys. Please. Even if they're not from your area, they could end up anywhere. They could pass through anywhere. And you could save a life. Again, I want to make this very clear. I, true crime, good Chief Klein, I am not complaining, directing, or accusing anyone of the disappearance of Sarah. All the information has been given to me by her mother, her last known appearance, who she was with, and the events and factors leading up to it. This info has been confirmed through Sarah's family, and I'm not making false statements, claims, or accusations on anyone. I am raising awareness on facts and hoping to bring Sarah home. So again, I'm not saying who I think did. I'm not saying who I think didn't do it. At this point, I just want Sarah home. I want her family to have answers. That's what's important. Figure out the rest later. Okay. I have been recovering from surgery, so I haven't been recording people, but I do want to give a quick shout out. Um, I will be interviewing Danny after dark, she's a true crime book nerd like me. And Trial to Rescue Coalition, Greg Schiller, who I met at CrimeCon. Um he helps bust predators online. I have Nicole and Jemmy coming up. She's a pathologist, an author of an anatomy book. Joe Scott Morgan, who's a distinguished scholar. He's the goat of true crime, a forensic and death investigator, and a professor at Jackson University in Alabama with a forensics lab and gets to show people how to do autopsies on cadavers. Like, how cool is that? Um, I also have some domestic violence survivors lined up. I have hopefully Cheryl McCollum. She's just so damn busy, but I want to talk about how she helped crack a cold case with the Flint River killer from behind bars, um, and a ton of other people. So things are picking up. I'm meeting some really cool people. Um, I'm I'm staying quiet right now about the Lala Clark case because, like I said, there's a gag order. There was supposed to be a hearing on July 29th, but they pushed up to September. So Candace can't give me any information. But we're supposed to go for Margarita soon. I saw a mean the other day because we were talking about it when I interviewed her last. I'm like, Senorita, we made Margaritas, and she's like, I did not forget. So that's in the works. Um, and you know, I want to end this episode with a quote on my arm that says, just be a nicer person. And it's a domestic violence weapon as the body of a butterfly and rainbow rings, because I love Lisa Frank. And just be a nicer person is Gabby Petito's quote. Now, I thought it was appropriate to get because growing up through high school, and now even now I always say to people, just be a good fucking person, it's not that fucking hard. So when I found out that her quote was just be a nicer person, I'm like, all right, this is less vulgar, I could put this on my body. And let me remind my listeners out there, especially the ones close to home who live in my community, who know what I'm talking about. If you don't want people knowing that you're a shitty person, guess what? Don't be a shitty person. If you don't want people thinking that you're a shitty person, guess what? Don't do shitty things. If you don't want people knowing that you're a liar or abuser or a cheater, guess what? Don't lie to cheat and abuse. It's that fucking simple. I'm a whistleblower and I will fucking whistle your ass out. I will tell everybody if you're an abuser to me, if you disrespect me, I don't give a shit, because guess what? That's my story. It's not, it's not defa um defamation and slander. When it's true, I have screenshots and proof to back it up and I lived it. If I'm a part of that story, guess what? It ain't slander, baby. That's my story. Now, there is a line when you can attack somebody's business, which I'm not doing, but I've been doing enough with a few different men and I don't put up with it. So um another phrase I always say if you see something, say something. Don't stay silent to make other people comfortable. Don't. It serves no purpose. I know people will see something and say, I don't want to get involved, but you getting involved can save a life. All right. So just be mindful. Be mindful of what you post, be mindful of how you treat people, be mindful of what you share, be mindful of putting your opinion and theories out there, guys. I'm telling you, I have seen it firsthand, throw in and uh hoot people. Just please try not to do it. Please. Please get the facts right, please get the evidence right, and correct it if you get it wrong and admit it. And please try to bring Sarah. Sarah Reynolds, born and raised in Nicholson, PA, went missing in New Hilford Township at the HO Mark Lassie off Route 492 at I81. You guys can follow me on Facebook, Instagram, and TikTok at True Crime with Tip Klein. You can also follow the Finding Jesse Farbler and Finding Sarah Reynolds Facebook pages. Huge resources to look at and um for updates. And finding Jesse Farbler pull you know promotes a lot of missing people. Such a good page and uh accurate information as well. And I do have another podcast called Turning the Corner, and it's more about domestic violence, um pod profits, missing persons, relationships, cheating, narcissism, uh anything really. Life. So some of my some of my podcasts from this one will cross over to that one because it kind of matches. Um, but that's turning the corner with a K K-O-R-N-E-R. My colors are still orange and yellow, um, which all came from Clients Corner, my food photography business starting in 2013. So I've tried to keep the you know motif the same because of branding. But um I I thank you all for sharing everything. I thank you all for the follows, I thank you all for the messages and the support and for supporting Sarah's family and really trying to bring her home. And um, I've had very, very, very few people come at me, and I've had very few people put their theory online, which isn't fun. Just just post the flyers, guys. That that's all you need to do right now. Um just stay tuned for more updates. Anything I get from her mom that I permission to update you all, I will. Um I'm gonna start trying to do some more shorts on videos because I know y'all like videos. I just don't like videos, but um, I'll try my best, guys. But um, I'm more of a blogger, behind the microphone type of person. Um most of the time, because I look like shit and I feel like shit, but um it's funny because when I was little I used to want to be a radio DJ. And when I ended up in radio sales, now I have a podcast. So it's like, oh, being full circle. Like, so weird. Um, but again, please keep your eyes out for Sarah. Should we share any missing person's wire you can? Just check for updates, and again, this is true cry with Tiff Klein giving criminals the disrespect they deserve.